CMS proposes CRUSH rule to expand Medicare Advantage audits and enrollment safeguards
CMS projects nearly $90 billion in 10-year savings, and officials say it would come entirely from more aggressive Medicare Advantage audits; comments are due Jan. 19, 2027.

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services filed the proposed Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare rule, CMS-6098-P, on Nov. 16, CASRAI reported. The 545-page proposal was placed on public inspection at 4:15 p.m. Eastern time and is scheduled for Federal Register publication on Nov. 19. It would apply to Medicare, Medicaid, CHIP and the health-insurance Marketplaces. Comments are due Jan. 19, 2027, according to Medical Daily. The proposal is not final; its provisions would take effect only through a subsequent finalization process.
The proposal would set a single 30-day deadline for providers and suppliers to report all changes to enrollment information, replacing current deadlines that vary from 30 to 90 days, CASRAI noted. It would give CMS stronger authority to deny or revoke enrollment when owners or locations cannot be confirmed or create an outsized risk of fraud, waste or abuse, McKnight’s Home Care reported. Providers and suppliers that bill Medicare Advantage would be required to enroll in Original Medicare, allowing CMS to screen them, including through fingerprint background checks, Medical Daily reported. That Medicare Advantage enrollment condition would start only with the first plan year that begins at least two years after a final rule appears.
Medicaid changes would add grounds to deny or terminate provider enrollment that align with Medicare, expand disclosure requirements for owning and managing parties, and require states to report more data, including National Provider Identifiers and addresses, McKnight’s Home Care reported. States would also be able to rely on a CMS or other federal agency determination to conclude that a credible allegation of fraud exists. For the Marketplaces, agents and brokers who have particular felony convictions or are currently excluded from federal health programs would be prohibited, CMS would be able to suspend a broker immediately, for no more than 90 days, when a credible allegation of abusive conduct exists, and brokers would be blocked from reaching Marketplace systems from outside the United States, Medical Daily reported.
Medical equipment suppliers would be allowed to reach seniors only in ways that do not include unsolicited phone calls, which Medicare already bars, or, under the proposal, unsolicited texts, direct messages on social media, emails lacking an opt-out, or in-person visits at the door, Medical Daily reported.
On savings, HHS projects nearly $90 billion over ten years. According to STAT, Officials at the Medicare agency stated that the projected savings would stem entirely from more aggressive audits of Medicare Advantage plans, not from stopping fraud in original Medicare. The proposal would require risk adjustment data validation audits that check whether diagnoses reported by plans are supported by patients’ medical records. CMS projects that the expanded audits would recover roughly $9 billion on average for each payment year, beginning with payment year 2018, according to Medical Daily.
The approach has been litigated. Humana brought a lawsuit against the prior RADV rule in 2023, and a federal judge in Texas struck it down in September 2025, ruling that CMS failed to provide sufficient notice. The department appealed, and an appeals court heard oral arguments in October, Medical Daily reported, citing Becker’s Hospital Review.
The new proposal follows an earlier CMS request for information on fraud prevention with a March 30, 2026 comment deadline, CASRAI reported. The Personalized Medicine Coalition responded to that request on March 30, 2026, supporting efforts to stop fraudulent payments while warning that growing use of genetic and molecular testing should not by itself be viewed as fraud, CASRAI reported. Comments on the current proposal may be submitted electronically to docket number CMS-2026-0826 with file code CMS-6098-P, CASRAI noted.
Kim Brandt, CMS deputy administrator and chief operating officer, said, “Behind every fraudulent claim is a real person,” Medical Daily reported.
Sources: McKnights Home Care, STAT, CASRAI, Medical Daily
Owen Hargrove Agencies and regulation correspondent
Owen Hargrove covers the cabinet departments, federal agencies and the rules they write for West Wing Times. Owen writes from Federal Register notices, agency announcements and published reporting.
Corrections. Report an error to corrections@westwingtimes.com. We list substantive corrections on the corrections page.