Sunday, November 15, 2026 Washington. Times are Eastern.

Workforce

Unions Sue OPM Over Forced Ratings and Suitability Rules

Four unions filed suit in California federal court Aug. 24, saying the rules exceed OPM's authority and violate the Civil Service Reform Act.

Entrance to the Office of Personnel Management headquarters at the Theodore Roosevelt Building in Washington, DC.
The entrance to the Office of Personnel Management headquarters at the Theodore Roosevelt Building in Washington, DC. Photograph: G. Edward Johnson/Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0)

As of early September 2026, a lawsuit by four federal unions is moving through the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, with forced-distribution performance deadlines set for Sept. 20 and Oct. 1. The unions filed the suit Aug. 24 to block final Office of Personnel Management rules on performance ratings and suitability, FEDweek reported Aug. 25, and Maryland Matters reported Aug. 26 that the plaintiffs are the American Federation of Government Employees, the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, the National Federation of Federal Employees, and the International Federation of Professional and Technical Engineers.

How the rules developed

The rules at issue were issued in three steps. ICLG reported Aug. 26 that a March 2026 Suitability Action Appeals rule stripped employees of the right to an independent review of suitability actions. In June, OPM finalized a Suitability and Fitness rule allowing agencies to apply to current employees the same suitability standards used for job applicants, and to direct removal of employees deemed unsuitable. In July, OPM finalized a Performance Appraisal rule that ends the decades-long ban on forced distribution of performance ratings and removes employees' ability to challenge ratings through grievance and arbitration.

OPM Director Scott Kupor laid out the agency's case for the performance changes in a Washington Post opinion piece Aug. 20, writing that his office is reviving "the most important metric" for federal workers and that rewarding excellence and punishing underperformance should not be so difficult. FEDagent reported Aug. 27 that OPM told FEDweek the new standardized rating system applies to the fiscal 2026 and fiscal 2027 appraisal cycles; agencies must establish a calibration program for the fiscal 2026 closeout by Sept. 20, 2026, and have new General Schedule performance management systems approved by OPM before Oct. 1, 2026 for fiscal 2027.

What the rules require

The performance rule does not yet set a specific distribution, but a manual OPM described as not a formal memorandum gives an example of 10 percent of employees rated Level 5 outstanding, with a possible range of 5 to 15 percent, and 20 percent rated Level 4 exceeds fully successful, with a range of 15 to 25 percent. OPM said the overhaul is needed to cut ratings inflation, noting that in 2024, 43 percent of employees below the senior level received a Level 5 outstanding rating.

The unions argue that forced distribution judges employees against one another rather than against objective criteria, violating the Civil Service Reform Act. In a joint statement, they said large numbers of high performers will be rated lower "for no reason other than the curve, and a lower rating makes them easier to discipline and easier to fire". FEDmanager reported Sept. 1 that AFGE National President Everett Kelley said public servants are "hired, judged and fired on merit, not on politics," and that OPM does not have authority to write those protections out of the law.

On suitability, the unions say OPM has given itself power to order firings and then review its own decision. The FEDweek report notes the rule's impact will be substantial: OPM itself estimates that half of all removal actions previously handled through Civil Service Reform Act procedures will now become suitability actions taken by OPM, and the rule bars employees fired through suitability actions from appealing to the Merit Systems Protection Board and Federal Circuit. OPM said its adjudicators will be insulated from officials who participated in the underlying action. The unions said the suitability standards are broad and subjective, calling them "an open invitation to fire public servants who speak out".

OPM did not comment on the lawsuit, citing a policy against discussing pending litigation. The case is the latest in a series of union challenges to the administration's workforce rules; the Sept. 20 calibration deadline and Oct. 1 system approval date are the next markers.

Sources: The Washington Post, FEDweek, Maryland Matters, ICLG, FEDagent, FEDmanager

Teresa Lindqvist Federal workforce correspondent

Teresa Lindqvist covers federal employees, pay, hiring and contracting for West Wing Times. Teresa writes from agency memos, Office of Personnel Management guidance, contract notices and published reporting.

Corrections. Report an error to corrections@westwingtimes.com. We list substantive corrections on the corrections page.