Sunday, November 22, 2026 Washington. Times are Eastern.

Oversight

GAO finds CMS fraud process misses Medicare fraud risks

The Center for Program Integrity's fraud risk process does not assess likelihood, impact, or whether controls fit Medicare's $481 billion program.

Illustration: CMS headquarters Baltimore
Illustration: West Wing Times

The Government Accountability Office said in a report released Wednesday, GAO-27-109072, that the Center for Program Integrity within the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services does not fully identify and assess the fraud risks facing the traditional Medicare fee-for-service program. The report, titled Medicare: HHS and CMS Should Better Manage Fraud Risks, says CMS paid out almost $481 billion in 2025 for roughly 34 million Medicare beneficiaries.

CMS and the contractors it works with run the fee-for-service part of Medicare. The agency uses the Vulnerability Management Process within the Center for Program Integrity to manage fraud risks. GAO said the process covers more ground and still misses many fraud risks Medicare faces. Because it falls short of recommended fraud risk practices, CPI misses chances to stop fraud before it becomes substantial, the report said.

GAO examined inspectors general reports, court filings, and contractor interviews to identify Medicare fraud risks. That work found fraud risks in Medicare that the Vulnerability Management Process had not flagged or evaluated. GAO said the process also fails to match other practices that support strategic fraud risk management. For instance, it never measures how likely fraud risks are or how severe their impact could be, and it does not check whether existing controls are adequate for Medicare.

As an example, GAO said CPI found a weakness tied to how Medicare screens suppliers when they enroll. GAO called that weakness a major fraud risk because it was tied to cases in which Medicare fraud was alleged. But CPI's assessment never evaluated the vulnerability's likelihood or impact. Without that assessment, GAO said, CPI may miss how broad and damaging the fraud risks are.

Medicare remains on GAO's high-risk list because it is large, complex, touches the federal budget and the health care industry, and remains exposed to fraud, mismanagement, and improper payments. GAO reviewed Medicare risk assessment documents and guidance, analyzed inspectors general reports, court filings, and contractor interviews, and spoke with CPI, CMS, and the Office of the Assistant Secretary for Financial Resources. It compared what it found with GAO's Fraud Risk Framework and internal control standards.

Update, November 19, 2026

The Department of Health and Human Services concurred with three of the four recommendations in the Government Accountability Office's Medicare fraud-risk report but rejected the call to revise the Center for Program Integrity's Vulnerability Management Process, Executive Gov reported Thursday. HHS said the watchdog misread that process and that CMS already runs full Medicare fraud-risk assessments routinely. GAO stood by all four recommendations, saying CMS's process treats fraud together with other program-integrity risks rather than evaluating it separately.

HHS also said it would establish a routine channel for the department's financial resources office to receive Medicare fraud risk information from CPI. Officials in that office told auditors they had not evaluated CPI's process. HHS accepted two recommendations to finalize draft guidance, risk assessments and vulnerability summaries, but said CMS would instead add "as-of" dates to continually updated documents; GAO said that step would not fully address the recommendations.

Sources: GAO reports, Executive Gov

Malik Osei Oversight correspondent

Malik Osei covers inspectors general, the Government Accountability Office and federal spending for West Wing Times. Malik writes from audit reports, budget documents and published reporting, and links every source.

Corrections. Report an error to corrections@westwingtimes.com. We list substantive corrections on the corrections page.